For the best mail order steaks in this lineup, I’d start with the Omaha Steaks Steakhouse Favorites 29-Piece Assortment for its mix of cuts and easy meal planning. MeatWorks USDA Prime 8-Steak Assortment stands out for shoppers prioritizing a higher USDA grade, while Rastelli’s 100% Grass-Fed Beef Pack suits buyers who want grass-fed beef in a larger bundle. The main tradeoffs are variety versus focusing on a favorite cut, a premium grade versus a larger quantity, and convenience versus having to manage a substantial freezer order. Shipping format and portion sizes matter, too, especially if you’re sending a gift or cooking for a small household. Read on for the full breakdown and help matching a steak box to your table.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- Mixed assortments lead on flexibility: Omaha Steaks’ 29-piece Steakhouse Favorites box offers more meal variety than single-cut packs, though a large assortment may include items you do not need.
- USDA grade and cut are separate decisions: MeatWorks offers a Prime assortment, while several Grumpy Butcher options focus on Choice steaks; the grade alone does not tell you which cut suits your cooking style.
- Grass-fed packs are a preference-led purchase: Rastelli’s 9.75-pound pack and Thomas Farms’ 16 ribeyes serve buyers looking for grass-fed beef, but their bulk format calls for freezer space and planned use.
- Portion size changes the value calculation: Kansas City Steak Company’s 22-ounce porterhouses are substantial servings, while individually sealed six-ounce filets make portion control easier.
- Gift-ready variety and focused steak boxes serve different needs: Omaha’s Grilling Gift Assortment includes 25 items, while the Rancher’s Butcher NY strip and filet box keeps attention on two classic steak cuts.
| Omaha Steaks Steakhouse Favorites, 29-Piece Assortment |  | Best for Mixed-Menu Variety | Total pieces: 29 | Top sirloins: 4 at 5 oz each | Other proteins: 4 chicken breasts at 5 oz each; 4 pork chops at 6 oz each; 4 burgers at 6 oz each; 4 jumbo franks at 3 oz each | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Rastelli’s 100% Grass-Fed Beef Pack, 9.75 lbs |  | Best Grass-Fed Beef Variety | Total weight: 9.75 lb | Beef: 100% grass-fed and finished | Filet mignon: 2 portions at 6 oz each | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Rancher’s Butcher Premium Steak Gift Box – NY Strip & Filet Mignon |  | Best for Steak Gifts | Beef grade: USDA Choice Angus | New York strip: 2 steaks | Filet mignon: 2 center-cut steaks | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Grumpy Butcher Premium 8-Steak Set, USDA Choice, 5 lb |  | Best Three-Cut Steak Assortment | Set size: 8 steaks | Total weight: 5 lb | Grade: USDA Choice | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Top Sirloin Steaks, 6 Pack |  | Best for Straightforward Sirloin Portions | Cut: Top sirloin | Grade: USDA Choice | Quantity: 6 steaks | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Grumpy Butcher Filet Mignon Steaks, 6 Pack |  | Best for a Special-Occasion Dinner | Cut: Filet mignon | Quantity: 6 steaks | Portion size: 8 oz each | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Taste of the Midwest Steak Variety Pack – Kansas City Strip & Top Sirloin with Cooking Instructions |  | Best for Cut Variety and Guided Cooking | Kansas City strip: 2 steaks, 10 oz each | Top sirloin: 2 steaks, 6 oz each | Aging: Up to 28 days | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Ribeye Steaks, 4-Pack, 3 lb |  | Best for Ribeye Fans | Cut: Ribeye | Grade: USDA Choice | Quantity: 4 steaks | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Omaha Steaks Grilling Gift Assortment, 25 Items |  | Best Mixed Grill Gift | Total items: 25 | Top sirloin filets: 4, 5 oz each | Chicken breasts: 4, 4 oz each | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice New York Strip Steaks, 8-Pack |  | Best for Feeding a Group | Cut: New York strip | Grade: USDA Choice | Quantity: 8 steaks | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MeatWorks USDA Prime 8-Steak Assortment Box |  | Best Premium Variety Box | Brand: MeatWorks | Grade: USDA Prime | Quantity: 8 steaks | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Thomas Farms Grass-Fed Ribeye Steaks, 10 oz Each, 16 Steaks |  | Best for Grass-Fed and Halal Buyers | Brand: Thomas Farms | Cut: Ribeye | Quantity: 16 steaks | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Kansas City Steak Company Porterhouse Steaks, 4 Count, 22 oz Each |  | Best for Large-Cut Steakhouse Meals | Cut: Porterhouse | Quantity: 4 steaks | Weight per steak: 22 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 10 Individually Sealed 6 oz Filet Mignon Steaks |  | Best for Smaller Filet Portions | Cut: Filet mignon | Quantity: 10 steaks | Weight per steak: 6 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Steak Trio, 3 Pack, 1.9 lb |  | Best Compact Cut Sampler | Brand: Grumpy Butcher | Grade: USDA Choice | Cuts: New York strip, ribeye, and filet mignon | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| mail order steak | Packaging | Quantity |
|---|---|---|
| Omaha Steaks Steakhouse Favori | — | — |
| Rastelli’s 100% Grass-Fed Beef | — | — |
| Rancher’s Butcher Premium Stea | Gift box; flash-frozen | — |
| Grumpy Butcher Premium 8-Steak | Vacuum-sealed; blast-frozen and shipped in insulated packaging | — |
| Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Top | Vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen | 6 steaks |
| Grumpy Butcher Filet Mignon St | Individually vacuum-sealed | 6 steaks |
| Taste of the Midwest Steak Var | Flash-frozen and vacuum-sealed | — |
| Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Rib | Vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen | 4 steaks |
| Omaha Steaks Grilling Gift Ass | — | — |
| Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice New | Individually vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen | 8 steaks |
| MeatWorks USDA Prime 8-Steak A | — | 8 steaks |
| Thomas Farms Grass-Fed Ribeye | — | 16 steaks |
| Kansas City Steak Company Port | Individually vacuum-sealed | 4 steaks |
| 10 Individually Sealed 6 oz Fi | Individually sealed | 10 steaks |
| Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Ste | — | 3 steaks |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Omaha Steaks Steakhouse Favorites, 29-Piece Assortment
I’d choose this assortment when the goal is to stock more than steak: its 29 pieces span beef, chicken, pork, burgers, franks, sides, and dessert, making it more adaptable for a household with different tastes than Rancher’s Butcher Premium Steak Gift Box, which focuses on four steaks. The top sirloins are aged for at least 28 days, and the individually sealed proteins can thaw in cold water in as little as 15 minutes—a useful shortcut when dinner plans change. The tradeoff is that only four pieces are top sirloin; much of the box is not steak, so it is a weaker fit for buyers seeking a steak-focused shipment. I’d also plan freezer space and account for the dry-ice delivery.
Pros:- Includes multiple proteins, sides, dessert, and seasoning
- Top sirloins are aged for at least 28 days
- Individually sealed proteins can thaw in cold water in as little as 15 minutes
- Variety can suit households with different meal preferences
Cons:- Only four of the 29 pieces are top sirloins
- Requires freezer storage and thawing
- Dry ice requires care when unpacking
Best for: Households that want a mix of steaks, other proteins, sides, and dessert in one freezer shipment.
Not ideal for: Steak purists or buyers with limited freezer space who want several portions of one steak cut.
- Total pieces:29
- Top sirloins:4 at 5 oz each
- Other proteins:4 chicken breasts at 5 oz each; 4 pork chops at 6 oz each; 4 burgers at 6 oz each; 4 jumbo franks at 3 oz each
- Sides and dessert:4 scalloped potatoes at 3.8 oz each; 4 caramel apple tartlets at 4 oz each
- Seasoning:1 packet, 3 oz
- Beef aging:At least 28 days
- Shipping:Flash-frozen and packed with dry ice
Our verdict“Choose this box for a varied household freezer stock, not for a steak-only assortment.”
Rastelli’s 100% Grass-Fed Beef Pack, 9.75 lbs
This is the strongest choice here for buyers who want grass-fed and finished beef across several meal types, rather than a single premium steak cut. Its 9.75 pounds include filet mignon, ribeye, New York strip, sirloin, burgers, and ground beef; that makes it more useful for building varied meals than Grumpy Butcher’s 8-Steak Set, which sticks to three steak cuts. The beef is raised without antibiotics or added hormones, then vacuum-sealed individually and flash-frozen for portion-by-portion storage. The tradeoff is a broad mix rather than a deep supply of any one steak: the filet and ribeye quantities are just two portions apiece. I’d pick it for a buyer who values production standards and freezer flexibility over concentrating the shipment on steaks alone.
Pros:- Includes filet mignon, ribeye, New York strip, sirloin, burgers, and ground beef
- Beef is 100% grass-fed and finished
- Raised without antibiotics or added hormones
- Individual vacuum sealing and flash-freezing support portioned storage
Cons:- Only two portions each of filet mignon, ribeye, and New York strip
- Three pounds of the total are ground beef rather than steaks
- Requires substantial freezer space
Best for: Buyers seeking a substantial freezer supply of grass-fed beef in steak, burger, and ground-beef formats.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who want a box dedicated to steak cuts or multiple portions of one favored steak.
- Total weight:9.75 lb
- Beef:100% grass-fed and finished
- Filet mignon:2 portions at 6 oz each
- Ribeye and New York strip:2 portions of each cut at 10 oz each
- Sirloin:4 portions at 6 oz each
- Burgers:6 portions at 5.33 oz each
- Ground beef:3 packs at 1 lb each; 85/15 blend
- Processing and sourcing:Individually vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen; no antibiotics or added hormones
Our verdict“Pick this pack if grass-fed beef variety matters more than getting a large run of one steak cut.”
For a gift centered on two classic steakhouse cuts, this box keeps the choice simple: two New York strips and two center-cut filet mignons, made with USDA Choice Angus beef and naturally aged. Hand-trimming for consistent thickness can make cooking more predictable, while flash-freezing is intended to preserve tenderness and juiciness through shipment. Compared with Grumpy Butcher’s Premium 8-Steak Set, this is a smaller, more focused presentation rather than a freezer-stock assortment with ribeyes and more portions. That focus is also the limitation: there is no ribeye, and four steaks offer less flexibility for a larger gathering. I’d choose it for a recipient who appreciates a paired cut selection and gift-box presentation, but skip it if variety or a larger quantity matters more.
Pros:- Combines New York strip and center-cut filet mignon
- Made with USDA Choice Angus beef
- Naturally aged beef
- Hand-trimmed steaks are cut for consistent thickness
Cons:- Only four steaks are included
- No ribeye or other cut options
- Offers less quantity and variety than Grumpy Butcher’s 8-Steak Set
Best for: Gift buyers choosing a compact, steak-focused box for someone who enjoys both strip steak and filet mignon.
Not ideal for: Hosts feeding a larger group or steak fans who specifically want ribeye or a broader cut selection.
- Beef grade:USDA Choice Angus
- New York strip:2 steaks
- Filet mignon:2 center-cut steaks
- Total quantity:4 steaks
- Aging:Naturally aged
- Preparation:Hand-trimmed for consistent thickness
- Packaging:Gift box; flash-frozen
Our verdict“Choose this gift box for a focused strip-and-filet pairing, not for a crowd-sized assortment.”
Grumpy Butcher Premium 8-Steak Set, USDA Choice, 5 lb
I’d rank this set highly for buyers who want three familiar steak cuts in one shipment without adding burgers or other proteins. The eight steaks include New York strip, filet mignon, and ribeye, giving a cook options for different preferences and preparations. That makes it more steak-focused than Omaha Steaks Steakhouse Favorites, where sides, dessert, and non-beef proteins make up much of the assortment. Each steak is vacuum-sealed, and the set is blast-frozen for shipment in insulated packaging. The tradeoff is that this is a USDA Choice assortment rather than a grass-fed selection like Rastelli’s pack, and the steaks arrive frozen. A gift box is available only as an add-on, so the standard presentation may be less gift-ready than Rancher’s Butcher’s dedicated gift box.
Pros:- Includes ribeye, filet mignon, and New York strip
- Eight steaks total for several meals or diners
- Individually vacuum-sealed
- Blast-frozen and shipped in insulated packaging
Cons:- Ships frozen and requires freezer storage
- USDA Choice grade may not suit buyers specifically seeking grass-fed or another stated production standard
- Gift box is an optional add-on
Best for: Households or hosts who want several servings across ribeye, filet mignon, and New York strip.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking grass-fed beef, fresh-shipped steaks, or a gift box included as standard.
- Set size:8 steaks
- Total weight:5 lb
- Grade:USDA Choice
- New York strip:4 steaks at 10 oz each
- Filet mignon:2 steaks at 8 oz each
- Ribeye:2 steaks at 12 oz each
- Packaging:Vacuum-sealed; blast-frozen and shipped in insulated packaging
Our verdict“Choose this set for a steak-focused mix of three classic cuts, provided frozen delivery and USDA Choice fit your preferences.”
Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Top Sirloin Steaks, 6 Pack
This pack suits buyers who prefer a consistent run of individually portioned top sirloin over a mixed-cut sampler. Six 6-ounce steaks make meal planning simple, and USDA Choice beef gives the box a defined grade. Compared with Grumpy Butcher’s Premium 8-Steak Set, it offers fewer cuts and less total weight, but avoids paying freezer space to cuts a buyer may not want. The steaks are aged, trimmed, vacuum-sealed, and flash-frozen, with insulated cold-chain packaging for delivery. The tradeoff is limited variety: there is no ribeye, filet, or strip steak to alternate with the sirloin. It’s a practical choice for repeatable portions, though buyers seeking a more celebratory gift presentation should note that the gift box is optional.
Pros:- Six individually portioned 6-ounce steaks
- USDA Choice beef
- Aged and trimmed before packing
- Vacuum-sealed and shipped flash-frozen in insulated packaging
Cons:- Only one cut is included
- Six-ounce portions may be small for buyers who prefer larger steaks
- Gift box is optional, and steaks arrive frozen
Best for: Meal planners who want six same-sized sirloin portions for grilling or pan searing.
Not ideal for: Steak enthusiasts who want multiple cuts, larger portions, or a gift box included by default.
- Cut:Top sirloin
- Grade:USDA Choice
- Quantity:6 steaks
- Weight per steak:6 oz
- Preparation:Aged and trimmed
- Packaging:Vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen
- Shipping:Insulated cold-chain packaging
- Gift box:Optional
Our verdict“Choose this pack for consistent, modest sirloin portions rather than the broader cut selection in the 8-Steak Set.”
Grumpy Butcher Filet Mignon Steaks, 6 Pack
For a mail-order steak dinner where tenderness and tidy portions matter more than a range of cuts, this six-pack of filet mignon is a focused pick. Each steak is 8 ounces, aged, and individually vacuum-sealed, so you can thaw only what you plan to serve and keep the rest frozen. Compared with the Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Ribeye Steaks, 4-Pack, this set offers more individual portions and a leaner, milder cut; the ribeye is the better fit for shoppers seeking richer marbling and beefier flavor. The tradeoff is that filet is less suited to buyers who want a boldly flavored, fatty steak, and six filets make less sense for someone looking to sample different cuts. Flash-frozen, insulated shipping supports freezer storage, but these steaks still need thawing and careful cooking to avoid drying out.
Pros:- Six individually portioned 8-ounce steaks make serving straightforward.
- Aged filet mignon is suited to diners who favor a tender, milder cut.
- Vacuum-sealed portions let you store and thaw steaks separately.
- Flash-frozen, insulated shipping supports freezer storage after delivery.
Cons:- A single cut gives less variety than the Taste of the Midwest Steak Variety Pack.
- The leaner filet may disappoint buyers seeking the richer flavor of ribeye.
- Requires freezer space and thawing before cooking.
Best for: Hosts planning a steak-focused dinner who want six individually portioned, tender filets and the option to thaw steaks as needed.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who prefer well-marbled, assertive beef flavor or want a mix of cuts rather than six filets.
- Cut:Filet mignon
- Quantity:6 steaks
- Portion size:8 oz each
- Total weight:3 lb
- Packaging:Individually vacuum-sealed
- Shipping condition:Flash-frozen in insulated cold-chain packaging
Our verdict“Choose this six-pack for a freezer-ready supply of individually sealed filets, but pick the ribeye set if marbling matters more than a tender, leaner cut.”
Taste of the Midwest Steak Variety Pack – Kansas City Strip & Top Sirloin with Cooking Instructions
This pack makes the most sense for buyers who want to compare two familiar steak styles without committing to a large single-cut order. It includes two 10-ounce Kansas City strips and two 6-ounce top sirloins, aged up to 28 days, plus seasoning and step-by-step cooking instructions. That guidance gives newer home cooks a practical starting point, while the mix lets a household choose between a fuller strip portion and a leaner sirloin. Against the Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice New York Strip Steaks, 8-Pack, this assortment offers more cut variety and cooking help, but far fewer steaks overall and no stated USDA grade. The smaller sirloins may not satisfy big appetites, and four portions are a limited fit for larger gatherings. Flash-frozen, vacuum-sealed packaging is freezer-friendly, though storage and thawing are part of the mail-order routine.
Pros:- Combines Kansas City strip and top sirloin for a choice of cuts.
- Steaks are aged up to 28 days.
- Cooking instructions offer a useful guide for less-experienced steak cooks.
- Seasoning packet and vacuum-sealed, flash-frozen packaging are included.
Cons:- Only four steaks are included, limiting its usefulness for a larger barbecue.
- Two sirloin portions are 6 ounces each and may feel small to hearty eaters.
- The supplied details do not specify a USDA grade.
Best for: Home cooks who want to try strip and sirloin, appreciate included cooking directions, and are serving a small household.
Not ideal for: Large gatherings or diners seeking equal, generous portions; the pack has only four steaks, including two 6-ounce sirloins.
- Kansas City strip:2 steaks, 10 oz each
- Top sirloin:2 steaks, 6 oz each
- Aging:Up to 28 days
- Packaging:Flash-frozen and vacuum-sealed
- Included items:Seasoning packet and cooking instructions
- Total steak count:4 steaks
Our verdict“Pick this pack for a small meal with two cut styles and cooking guidance; choose the eight-steak New York strip pack when serving more people.”
Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Ribeye Steaks, 4-Pack, 3 lb
For shoppers who put marbling and rich beef flavor ahead of portion count, this four-pack gives each diner a substantial 12-ounce USDA Choice ribeye. The steaks are aged, vacuum-sealed, and flash-frozen, with preparation options ranging from grilling to cast-iron cooking. Compared with the Grumpy Butcher Filet Mignon Steaks, 6 Pack, this set trades two portions for a cut with a fuller, richer profile; the filets are a better match for diners who favor a leaner, more tender steak. The tradeoff is clear: four steaks suit a smaller table, not a large gathering, and the product requires freezer space until you are ready to cook. USDA Choice identifies the stated grade, but buyers seeking a different grade or multiple cuts should compare other assortments rather than treating this as a sampler.
Pros:- Four 12-ounce ribeyes provide substantial individual portions.
- USDA Choice grade and aging are specified.
- Ribeye suits buyers seeking richer flavor and a tender texture.
- Can be grilled, pan-seared, broiled, or cooked in cast iron.
Cons:- Four steaks offer less serving capacity than the eight-steak New York strip pack.
- A single-cut pack does not provide variety for different preferences.
- Flash-frozen steaks require freezer storage and thawing.
Best for: Ribeye enthusiasts serving up to four people who want substantial portions and several familiar cooking methods.
Not ideal for: Hosts feeding a larger group, shoppers seeking multiple cuts, or diners who prefer a leaner steak like filet mignon.
- Cut:Ribeye
- Grade:USDA Choice
- Quantity:4 steaks
- Weight per steak:12 oz
- Total weight:3 lb
- Packaging:Vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen
- Cooking methods:Grilling, pan-searing, broiling, or cast-iron cooking
Our verdict“Choose this pack when rich ribeye flavor and 12-ounce portions are your priority; select the filets for a leaner cut or the variety pack for more options.”
Omaha Steaks Grilling Gift Assortment, 25 Items
This assortment is the lineup’s broadest choice for a mixed grill and gift-style spread, rather than a box centered on steak alone. It includes four 5-ounce top sirloin filets alongside chicken, burgers, jumbo franks, tartlets, and seasoning; the beef is aged for at least 28 days, and the proteins are individually sealed and shipped flash-frozen with dry ice. Compared with the Taste of the Midwest Steak Variety Pack, this box brings more kinds of food and dessert, but its steak portion is smaller and less central to the order. That makes it useful when guests want different options, but a poor match for anyone specifically seeking a supply of steak dinners. The individual seals and cold-water thawing option add flexibility; in return, buyers need freezer room and must plan around thawing before cooking.
Pros:- Includes beef, chicken, burgers, franks, dessert, and seasoning for a varied meal.
- Top sirloin filets are aged for at least 28 days.
- Individually sealed proteins can be thawed separately.
- Cold-water thawing may take as little as 15 minutes for individually sealed proteins.
Cons:- The steak portion is limited compared with dedicated steak packs.
- Multiple food types take freezer space and require planning to thaw.
- The assortment is less suitable for buyers who want one consistent steak cut.
Best for: Gift-givers or grill hosts serving guests with varied preferences who want steak, chicken, burgers, franks, dessert, and seasoning in one assortment.
Not ideal for: Steak-focused households seeking several full-size steaks; this assortment includes only four 5-ounce sirloin filets among 25 items.
- Total items:25
- Top sirloin filets:4, 5 oz each
- Chicken breasts:4, 4 oz each
- Classic burgers:8, 4 oz each
- Jumbo franks:4, 3 oz each
- Caramel apple tartlets:4, 4 oz each
- Beef aging:At least 28 days
- Shipping:Flash-frozen and packed with dry ice
- Thawing:Individually sealed proteins can thaw in cold water in as little as 15 minutes
Our verdict“Choose this assortment for a varied grill gift or crowd with different tastes, not for stocking up on steak as the main event.”
Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice New York Strip Steaks, 8-Pack
Among these five picks, this is the strongest fit for stocking a freezer ahead of a group steak meal: eight individually sealed, 10-ounce New York strips add up to five pounds of USDA Choice beef. The aged steaks have the hearty texture and rich flavor associated with strip, while separate packaging makes it easier to thaw the number you need rather than the full order. Compared with the Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Ribeye Steaks, 4-Pack, this set doubles the steak count and favors strip over ribeye’s richer profile. Its tradeoff is less cut variety, and the eight portions may be more than a small household wants to store or use soon. It ships flash-frozen in insulated packaging, so freezer capacity and thawing time belong in the plan. The optional gift box is an add-on, not part of the core steak count.
Pros:- Eight 10-ounce steaks offer more serving capacity than the four-steak ribeye pack.
- USDA Choice grade and aging are specified.
- Individual vacuum seals let buyers thaw portions separately.
- Suitable for grilling or pan-searing.
Cons:- Eight steaks require substantial freezer capacity and may be excessive for a small household.
- The pack includes only New York strip, with no cut variety.
- Steaks ship frozen and need thawing before cooking; gift box is an optional add-on.
Best for: Hosts planning several steak meals or serving a group who want consistent, individually sealed New York strips.
Not ideal for: Small households with limited freezer space, diners seeking ribeye or multiple cuts, or buyers expecting a gift box to be included by default.
- Cut:New York strip
- Grade:USDA Choice
- Quantity:8 steaks
- Weight per steak:10 oz
- Total weight:5 lb
- Preparation:Grilling or pan-searing
- Packaging:Individually vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen
- Shipping:Insulated packaging
Our verdict“Choose this pack for a group or multiple meals built around New York strip; pick the four-steak ribeye pack for a smaller table and a richer cut.”
MeatWorks USDA Prime 8-Steak Assortment Box
I’d choose the MeatWorks assortment when the goal is to send or serve several familiar steakhouse cuts in one shipment. Its four ribeyes, two New York strips, and two filets offer more variety than the Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Steak Trio, while the USDA Prime grade and 28-day wet-aging give this box a clear premium distinction. The mix also makes it easier to match different preferences at one meal, from richer ribeye to leaner filet.
The tradeoff is that this is a freezer-dependent gift, and the product data provides no thawing or cooking guidance. It also has fewer total steaks than a large assortment such as Omaha Steaks Steakhouse Favorites. I’d favor it for cut variety and grade over sheer quantity, but skip it if the recipient needs detailed preparation help.
Pros:- Includes ribeye, New York strip, and filet mignon for varied meals
- USDA Prime grade distinguishes it from the USDA Choice Grumpy Butcher Steak Trio
- Steaks are wet-aged for 28 days
- Flash-frozen for freezer storage and shipment
Cons:- Requires freezer space until the steaks are used
- No cooking or thawing instructions are provided
Best for: Gift buyers or households who want several classic cuts and value USDA Prime beef over a larger steak count.
Not ideal for: New steak cooks who need included thawing and cooking instructions, or buyers without freezer space.
- Brand:MeatWorks
- Grade:USDA Prime
- Quantity:8 steaks
- Ribeye:4 steaks, 12 oz. each
- New York strip:2 steaks, 12 oz. each
- Filet mignon:2 steaks, 8 oz. each
- Aging:Wet-aged for 28 days
- Storage:Flash-frozen
Our verdict“Choose this box for a premium, three-cut gift assortment; pick a larger set if steak count matters more than grade and variety.”
Thomas Farms Grass-Fed Ribeye Steaks, 10 oz Each, 16 Steaks
The Thomas Farms pack is the clearest fit here for buyers who prioritize grass-fed, grass-finished beef and Halal certification. Sixteen 10-ounce ribeyes make it a more substantial single-cut supply than the mixed MeatWorks USDA Prime 8-Steak Assortment, but there’s no option to switch to strip or filet. Its Australian origin, no added hormones or antibiotics, and perforated two-steak packs give buyers useful sourcing and storage details.
The format favors planned freezer meals: the steaks arrive frozen, and each pack contains two portions that can be separated for storage. At 10 ounces per steak, portions are smaller than the 22-ounce porterhouses from Kansas City Steak Company, though easier to portion for individual meals. Choose it for dietary requirements and repeat ribeye dinners; skip it if you want cut variety or larger steaks.
Pros:- 100% grass-fed and grass-finished beef raised in Australia
- Halal-certified and made without added hormones or antibiotics
- Sixteen steaks provide a sizable supply of one cut
- Perforated two-steak packs help with separating portions for storage
Cons:- Ribeye is the only cut included
- 10-ounce steaks are smaller than the Kansas City Steak Company 22-ounce porterhouses
- Frozen shipment requires freezer space
Best for: Halal-conscious households and grass-fed beef buyers who want a freezer supply of individually portioned ribeyes.
Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking a mix of cuts, very large steaks, or beef that is not shipped frozen.
- Brand:Thomas Farms
- Cut:Ribeye
- Quantity:16 steaks
- Weight per steak:10 oz
- Beef:100% grass-fed and grass-finished
- Origin:Australia
- Certification:Halal
- Packaging and shipping:Two steaks per perforated pack; frozen in insulated packaging with ice packs
Our verdict“Pick this pack if grass-fed, Halal ribeye is the priority; choose a mixed assortment if variety matters more.”
Kansas City Steak Company Porterhouse Steaks, 4 Count, 22 oz Each
For buyers who want a single, substantial steak to anchor dinner, these 22-ounce porterhouses are the most distinctive choice in this group. Each cut combines the strip and tenderloin sides, making it a bigger, more involved meal than the 6-ounce filets or the mixed, smaller portions in the Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Steak Trio. Aging for up to 28 days adds a clear preparation detail, while individual vacuum seals let you thaw one steak at a time.
The included seasoning pack and cooking instructions give this option an advantage for cooks who want guidance; the MeatWorks assortment does not include instructions. The tradeoff is portion size: four steaks may suit a special meal better than routine individual dinners, and they still need to be cooked at home. I’d skip them if a compact portion or ready-to-serve gift is the priority.
Pros:- Four large 22-ounce porterhouse steaks
- Aging of up to 28 days
- Individually vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen for separate storage
- Includes seasoning and grilling and broiling instructions
Cons:- Large portions may be too much for everyday individual meals
- Requires home cooking
- Offers porterhouse only, unlike the mixed-cut MeatWorks assortment
Best for: Home cooks planning hearty steakhouse-style dinners who want large porterhouses and included cooking guidance.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer modest portions, a selection of different cuts, or steaks that arrive ready to eat.
- Cut:Porterhouse
- Quantity:4 steaks
- Weight per steak:22 oz
- Aging:Aged up to 28 days
- Packaging:Individually vacuum-sealed
- Storage:Flash-frozen
- Included:Seasoning pack and cooking instructions
- Cooking guidance:Grilling and broiling tips
Our verdict“Choose these porterhouses for large, guided steakhouse-style meals rather than smaller portions or cut variety.”
10 Individually Sealed 6 oz Filet Mignon Steaks
This ten-pack makes the most sense for filet fans who want smaller, individually sealed portions ready to store separately. At 6 ounces each, these filets are a more restrained serving than the 8-ounce filets in the MeatWorks USDA Prime assortment, and the pack includes more filet portions overall. That single-cut focus can work well for a household that already knows what it likes, but it offers none of the ribeye or strip variety found in MeatWorks or the Grumpy Butcher trio.
The hand-cut, thick description and cooler shipment with dry ice or gel packs speak to handling and presentation, but the supplied details do not state a beef grade, aging method, or cooking directions. I’d choose it for portion control and separate storage, not for buyers comparing stated grades or seeking a guided steak experience. It also needs room for chilled or frozen storage on arrival.
Pros:- Ten filet mignon steaks in one shipment
- 6-ounce portions suit buyers seeking smaller steaks
- Individually sealed for separate storage
- Shipped in a cooler with dry ice or gel packs
Cons:- Includes filet mignon only, unlike the three-cut MeatWorks assortment
- Product details do not state a beef grade or aging method
- No cooking or thawing instructions are listed
Best for: Filet mignon enthusiasts who want multiple modest portions individually sealed for separate meals.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want stated USDA grade, several different cuts, or preparation instructions.
- Cut:Filet mignon
- Quantity:10 steaks
- Weight per steak:6 oz
- Preparation:Hand-cut and described as thick
- Packaging:Individually sealed
- Shipping:Cooler shipped
- Cooling materials:Dry ice or gel packs
Our verdict“Choose this pack for separately sealed, smaller filets, but opt for a mixed assortment if grade details or cut variety matter.”
Grumpy Butcher USDA Choice Steak Trio, 3 Pack, 1.9 lb
The Grumpy Butcher trio is the smallest, simplest way in this lineup to compare three classic cuts: New York strip, ribeye, and filet mignon. At 1.9 pounds total, it suits a couple or a small tasting-style meal better than the eight-steak MeatWorks USDA Prime assortment, which offers more portions and a higher stated grade. This box instead gives one steak of each cut, letting buyers try different textures and flavors without committing to a large single-cut pack.
All three steaks are USDA Choice, vacuum-sealed, flash-frozen, and shipped in insulated packaging. That is a useful storage format, though it still requires freezer space and home cooking. There are no included cooking instructions listed, unlike the Kansas City Steak Company porterhouses. I’d pick this trio for a compact sampler, but not for households needing repeat portions or seeking Prime grade.
Pros:- Includes New York strip, ribeye, and filet mignon
- Compact three-steak assortment totals 1.9 pounds
- USDA Choice grade is stated
- Vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen for insulated shipment
Cons:- Only one steak of each cut, limiting repeat meals
- USDA Choice grade is below the USDA Prime MeatWorks assortment
- Requires freezer storage and no cooking instructions are listed
Best for: Couples or small households who want one steak each of three familiar cuts without buying a large assortment.
Not ideal for: Families needing multiple portions per cut, or buyers prioritizing USDA Prime beef or included cooking guidance.
- Brand:Grumpy Butcher
- Grade:USDA Choice
- Cuts:New York strip, ribeye, and filet mignon
- Quantity:3 steaks
- Total weight:1.9 lb
- New York strip:10 oz
- Ribeye:12 oz
- Filet mignon:8 oz
- Packaging and shipping:Vacuum-sealed, flash-frozen, and shipped in insulated packaging
Our verdict“Choose this trio for a compact three-cut sampler; choose MeatWorks for more steaks and a stated Prime grade.”
How We Picked
I compared these 15 mail order steak options by looking at what a buyer can tell from the listed cut, USDA grade, total quantity, portion size, and assortment design. I gave weight to whether a box makes a clear case for a particular need—such as grass-fed beef, a premium grade, individual portions, or a range of cuts—rather than treating a larger bundle as automatically better. Gift suitability and ease of planning also mattered, since many mail order steak purchases are meant for sharing or sending.
The ranking favors options with a distinct, useful role and enough detail to help buyers match the box to their meals. Broad assortments rank well for flexibility, while focused packs rise when they serve a clear preference or cooking plan. I also account for tradeoffs: large bundles need freezer capacity, single-cut boxes offer less variety, and a stated grade does not replace choosing a cut you enjoy. Product details provided for this comparison do not establish shipping conditions or sourcing claims beyond the named attributes.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Mail Order Steaks
Before choosing a box, I’d match it to the way you actually buy and cook steak. A mail order assortment can look appealing on paper but become inconvenient if its portions, cut mix, or quantity do not fit your household. These factors help separate a suitable order from one that simply contains a lot of beef.
Choose Cuts Around Your Cooking Routine
Start with the cooking methods you use most, not the number of steaks in the box. Strip, sirloin, ribeye, filet, and porterhouse each produce a different meal, and a mixed assortment only helps if you’ll use its variety. A single-cut pack can make repeat dinners predictable, while a selection with multiple cuts gives you more room to match steak to a meal or guest. Buyers who are new to ordering steak may find a variety box easier to explore, but should check that the assortment does not include items they would leave unused. For a gift, familiar cuts can be safer than a box built around less familiar choices. I’d also plan sides and cooking time around the cut rather than assuming every steak in a box cooks alike.
Read Portion Size as Carefully as Pack Count
A pack of eight does not tell you how many people it will feed until you know the size of each steak. Large porterhouses can make a meal feel generous but may be unwieldy for diners who prefer smaller portions. Individually portioned filets are easier to allocate across meals, while larger or mixed packs may suit households that cook for several people at once. One common mistake is comparing total weight without checking the number and size of individual steaks. If you expect to serve guests, consider whether the cuts can be portioned or shared comfortably. For a smaller household, a box that can be divided into manageable meals may be more useful than the largest assortment.
Treat USDA Grade and Feeding Preference as Different Filters
USDA grade and grass-fed labeling answer different buyer questions. A Prime designation identifies a grading category, while grass-fed describes a feeding preference; neither label alone tells you whether the cut or box fits your taste and cooking habits. In this lineup, MeatWorks offers a Prime assortment, while Rastelli’s and Thomas Farms identify grass-fed options. Choice packs from Grumpy Butcher may appeal to shoppers seeking a particular familiar cut without selecting a Prime assortment. Avoid assuming that the grade is the only meaningful quality detail or that a feeding label guarantees a specific flavor preference. Choose the attribute you care about most, then compare cut, portion, and quantity within that group.
Plan Freezer Space Before Ordering in Bulk
Mail order steak boxes can vary from a handful of steaks to multi-pound assortments, so check the full quantity before placing an order. Bulk packs are more practical when you have freezer room and a plan for using the steaks across several meals. Individually sealed portions can make it easier to separate meals, but packaging details should be checked rather than assumed from the product name. A large mixed box may require more organization than a small pack of one cut. If you are ordering for someone else, confirm that they can store the shipment and use the contents; a generous gift can become a chore without enough freezer capacity. I’d make space first, then choose the box size.
Decide When Variety Is Worth More Than a Focused Box
Assortments trade precision for choice. A multi-item box can cover different meals or make a gift feel more varied, but you may receive cuts or other items that do not match your plans. Focused boxes—such as a ribeye pack or a NY strip and filet selection—make more sense when you already know what you like and want fewer surprises in the meal plan. Beginners may benefit from variety if the box gives them a chance to compare cuts, though a simpler pack can be easier to cook consistently. For gifting, consider whether the recipient enjoys experimenting or would rather receive a familiar steak. Pay more for breadth only when you expect to use that breadth.
Check Delivery and Handling Details at Checkout
The product name alone cannot tell you when a shipment will arrive or how it is packed for transit. Before ordering, check the seller’s current delivery window, shipment tracking, packaging description, and instructions for handling the box on arrival. This matters most for a scheduled gift or a delivery to a home where someone may not be present. Do not assume every seller uses the same shipping schedule or packaging method just because the products are all mail order steaks. If the order is time-sensitive, verify the delivery details directly before committing. Also check the seller’s policy for shipment problems so you know what steps to take if the package does not arrive as expected.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I choose a steak assortment or a box of one cut?
I’d choose an assortment if you want flexibility across meals or are buying for someone whose preferences are not fully known. A focused box makes more sense when you already know the household likes ribeye, filet, sirloin, or another specific cut. Assortments can reduce menu repetition, but they may include items you do not plan to cook. Single-cut packs make portion planning and repeat cooking simpler, though they offer less variety. Let your meal plan decide rather than assuming a larger mix is automatically a better fit.
Does USDA Prime matter more than choosing the right cut?
Not necessarily: grade and cut describe different things, so neither can stand in for the other. A Prime assortment may appeal if grade is your main priority, but a buyer who prefers a particular cut may be happier with a focused Choice pack. Think about how you like to cook and eat steak, then use grade as a further filter. The options in this roundup include both Prime and Choice offerings, as well as grass-fed packs, so the labels reflect different preferences. I’d prioritize a cut you enjoy before paying attention to grade alone.
How much steak should I order for a small household?
Start with how many steak meals you expect to cook and the listed portion size, then check the total weight and pack count. A multi-pound box can be sensible if you have freezer space and will use it over time, but it may be excessive if steak is only an occasional meal. Individually portioned six-ounce filets can offer a more controlled serving plan than large steaks intended for sharing. Do not use pack count by itself to estimate how long an order will last. If you are unsure, a smaller or more focused box can be easier to manage than a large mixed assortment.
Is a grass-fed mail order steak box right for every steak buyer?
No. Grass-fed labeling is useful if that feeding preference is part of your buying decision, but it does not make a box the right choice for someone who mainly wants a specific cut, assortment, or portion size. Compare the listed cuts and total quantity alongside the grass-fed claim. The Rastelli’s pack offers a larger mixed beef quantity, while Thomas Farms focuses on ribeyes, so the format matters as much as the label. If you have not chosen grass-fed before, consider whether the pack size and freezer commitment suit your household before ordering.
What should I verify before sending steak as a gift?
Check that the recipient can accept a perishable delivery and has room to store the shipment when it arrives. Confirm the seller’s delivery window, packaging information, and any handling instructions rather than relying on the product title. Then choose between a varied gift assortment and a focused box of familiar cuts based on what the recipient enjoys. Large boxes can feel generous but may be awkward for a small household or a recipient with limited freezer space. If timing matters, verify the current shipping details directly with the seller before placing the order.
Conclusion
For the best overall choice, I’d pick Omaha Steaks Steakhouse Favorites for buyers who want a broad assortment of meals in one box. Best value for a focused order depends on your preferred cut: the Grumpy Butcher Choice sirloin, ribeye, and NY strip packs each suit shoppers who want to stock one familiar steak style rather than pay for variety they may not use. For a premium-grade preference, MeatWorks’ USDA Prime assortment is the clearest fit; for grass-fed beef, compare Rastelli’s larger pack with Thomas Farms’ ribeye-focused box. Beginners may prefer an assortment with multiple cuts, while gift buyers can choose Omaha’s Grilling Gift Assortment for variety or Rancher’s Butcher for a more focused NY strip and filet pairing. If you want large individual steaks for sharing, Kansas City Steak Company’s porterhouses address that need; if portion control matters more, the individually sealed six-ounce filets are the more practical direction.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
