When I compare the best holiday spreads, I look beyond festive labels: the best jar depends on whether it needs to carry a brunch table, complement savory food, or make a small gift feel special. Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 12.5 Ounces is my pick for sharing because its pear, cranberry, raspberry, and orange liqueur blend comes in the largest listed jar. Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves suit shoppers who want a warmly spiced, more familiar flavor in a two-jar pack, while Stonewall Kitchen Apple Cranberry Chutney is the most flexible choice for crackers, cheese, and meals.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The main tradeoff is between sweet, breakfast-ready jam and a spread with enough tartness, spice, or savory character to work beyond toast. Jar size matters too: the 4-ounce Holiday Jam offers a small-format taste or gift, but it is less suited to a large gathering than its 12.5-ounce counterpart. I rank these four by their usefulness for holiday occasions, the distinctiveness of their flavors, and how clearly their serving formats fit different buyers.
Key Takeaways
- Best for a holiday table: Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 12.5 Ounces, gives hosts the largest listed jar of the pear, cranberry, raspberry, and orange liqueur blend.
- Best for warm seasonal flavor: Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves pair pumpkin with cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove and come as two 13-ounce glass jars.
- Best savory pairing: Apple Cranberry Chutney adds herbs and spices to sweet-tart fruit, making it the strongest fit for crackers, cheese, seasoned meats, and spicy meals.
- Best small-format option: The 4-ounce Holiday Jam keeps the same festive flavor in a compact jar, though its serving capacity is limited.
- Check the flavor and ingredient fit: Both Holiday Jam options include orange liqueur, and all four products contain sweet fruit preparations that may not suit every palate or use.
| Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 12.5 Ounces | ![]() | Best Overall for Holiday Hosting | Brand: Stonewall Kitchen | Product type: Holiday jam | Flavor blend: Pears, cranberries, raspberries, and orange liqueur | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves, 13 oz (Pack of 2) | ![]() | Best for Warm Seasonal Flavor | Flavor: Pumpkin spice | Net weight: 13 ounces per jar | Pack size: 2 jars | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Stonewall Kitchen Apple Cranberry Chutney, 8.5 oz | ![]() | Best for Cheese Boards and Savory Meals | Brand: Stonewall Kitchen | Product type: Apple cranberry chutney | Net weight: 8.5 ounces | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 4 oz | ![]() | Best Small-Format Gift or Tasting Jar | Brand: Stonewall Kitchen | Product type: Holiday jam | Flavor blend: Pears, cranberries, raspberries, and orange liqueur | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| holiday spread | Net weight | Brand | Product type | Flavor blend |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam | 12.5 ounces | Stonewall Kitchen | Holiday jam | Pears, cranberries, raspberries, and orange liqueur |
| Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Pres | 13 ounces per jar | — | — | — |
| Stonewall Kitchen Apple Cranbe | 8.5 ounces | Stonewall Kitchen | Apple cranberry chutney | — |
| Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam | 4 ounces | Stonewall Kitchen | Holiday jam | Pears, cranberries, raspberries, and orange liqueur |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 12.5 Ounces
This is my best overall holiday spread because it has the most useful balance of a festive flavor and a shareable format. Pears soften the tartness of cranberries, raspberries bring a brighter fruit note, and a hint of orange liqueur gives the blend a more occasion-specific character than a straightforward berry preserve. At 12.5 ounces, it is the larger of the two Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam options, so it makes more sense for a brunch table or a group sharing toast and pastries than the 4-ounce jar.
Compared with Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves, this jam leans toward tart fruit and citrus rather than cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove. That makes it the better match for people who want berries and fruit to lead, while Bonne Maman is a clearer choice for classic warm-spice cues. The chutney offers herbs and spices for savory dishes; this jam is more naturally at home on toast, pastries, or a festive breakfast spread. Its fruit blend may still complement a cheese board, but it is not described as an herb-forward accompaniment like the chutney.
The main compromise is the orange liqueur. Its presence helps distinguish the flavor, but it can rule the jar out for people avoiding alcohol or serving guests with related dietary preferences. The holiday-leaning blend may also feel less suited to everyday use than a simpler fruit preserve. I would choose this jar for a host who wants a distinctive sweet option with enough volume to share, not for someone who needs a neutral, all-purpose spread.
Pros:- The blend of pears, cranberries, and raspberries offers more complexity than a single-fruit jam.
- A hint of orange liqueur gives it a festive flavor profile distinct from the pumpkin-spice preserves.
- The 12.5-ounce jar is better suited to sharing than the 4-ounce Holiday Jam.
- Works as a holiday brunch or gifting choice when a fruit-forward spread is wanted.
Cons:- Contains orange liqueur, which may not fit every guest’s dietary preferences.
- The holiday-focused flavor may be less versatile for everyday use.
- Its sweet fruit profile is less directly suited to savory meals than the Apple Cranberry Chutney.
Best for: Hosts serving a holiday brunch or a shared table who want a distinctive pear, cranberry, raspberry, and orange liqueur jam in a larger jar.
Not ideal for: Anyone avoiding alcohol, seeking a mild year-round preserve, or prioritizing a savory, herb-forward spread.
- Brand:Stonewall Kitchen
- Product type:Holiday jam
- Flavor blend:Pears, cranberries, raspberries, and orange liqueur
- Net weight:12.5 ounces
- Origin:USA
- Container:Jar
Our verdict“I recommend the 12.5-ounce Holiday Jam for hosts who want a distinctive, shareable fruit spread and are comfortable serving a jam made with orange liqueur.”
Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves, 13 oz (Pack of 2)
For a holiday spread that tastes unmistakably seasonal, I would choose Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves. Pumpkin is paired with cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, creating a warmer, more familiar profile than the tart berry-and-citrus direction of either Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam. That difference matters at breakfast: this is the option I would reach for when toast, yogurt, or pastries need a spiced seasonal accent rather than a bright, tangy fruit note.
The format is a meaningful advantage. This listing includes two 13-ounce glass jars, which gives a buyer a jar to open and another to save, share, or use later. That is a different kind of hosting convenience than the single 12.5-ounce Stonewall Kitchen jar: the total amount is larger, but the two-jar setup may be easier to divide between a breakfast table and a gift. The ingredient description lists fruit, sugar, pectin, and lemon juice, and the product is identified as Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and certified kosher.
Its limitation is that pumpkin spice is a distinct seasonal preference, not a neutral choice for every household. Someone who favors tart cranberries or wants a spread for seasoned meats may find the Apple Cranberry Chutney more adaptable. This preserve is also sweet and contains sugar; its short ingredient list does not make it a low-sugar option. I rank it behind the large Holiday Jam because the jam’s fruit blend suits a wider range of holiday-table tastes, but Bonne Maman is the better match when warm spice is the point.
Pros:- Pumpkin with cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove delivers a clear warm-spice identity.
- Two 13-ounce glass jars offer a useful split between serving, storing, and gifting.
- The listed ingredients are fruit, sugar, pectin, and lemon juice.
- Identified as Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and certified kosher.
Cons:- The seasonal pumpkin-spice profile will not suit every taste or menu.
- Contains sugar, so it is not a fit for buyers seeking an unsweetened spread.
- Less directly suited to meats and savory meals than the Apple Cranberry Chutney.
Best for: Shoppers who want a warmly spiced breakfast spread, two full-size jars, and the listed gluten-free, kosher, and Non-GMO Project Verified attributes.
Not ideal for: People who dislike pumpkin spice, want a savory chutney, or need a spread without sugar.
- Flavor:Pumpkin spice
- Net weight:13 ounces per jar
- Pack size:2 jars
- Packaging:Glass jars
- Made in:France
- Ingredients:Fruit, sugar, pectin, and lemon juice
- Dietary attributes:Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, certified kosher
Our verdict“I would pick Bonne Maman for a two-jar supply of warm, spiced preserves, while choosing a Holiday Jam for tart berry fruit or the chutney for savory pairings.”
Stonewall Kitchen Apple Cranberry Chutney, 8.5 oz
The Apple Cranberry Chutney is my pick when a holiday spread needs to do more than sweeten toast. Its combination of apples, tart cranberries, herbs, and spices gives it a savory edge that separates it from the two Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jams and Bonne Maman’s pumpkin-spice preserves. The provided serving ideas include spicy meals, seasoned meats, and crackers with cheese, so it is the clearest choice here for a table that moves between snacks and the main meal.
Compared with the pear-and-berry Holiday Jam, this chutney sounds less like a brunch topping and more like a sweet-tart condiment. That difference gives it a useful role on a cheese board or beside seasoned food, where the jam’s orange liqueur and fruit-forward sweetness may not be the intended fit. It is also less narrowly seasonal in its listed pairings than pumpkin spice, although the apple-cranberry combination still has an autumnal, holiday-friendly feel. At 8.5 ounces, the jar sits between the small 4-ounce jam and the larger single jar or two-jar preserve pack in practical serving scale.
This versatility has a tradeoff: sweet-tart fruit, herbs, and spices will not suit every dish. Buyers wanting a straightforward sweet spread for pastries may prefer either Holiday Jam, while those seeking a warm pumpkin flavor should pick Bonne Maman. The supplied details do not specify dietary certifications or a full ingredient list, so I would not assume this chutney fits a particular dietary requirement. I rank it third overall because its savory usefulness is strong but more menu-dependent than the large Holiday Jam’s broad holiday-brunch role.
Pros:- Combines apples and tart cranberries with herbs and spices for a more savory character.
- Listed pairings include meals, seasoned meats, crackers, and cheese.
- More directly suited to savory serving than either Holiday Jam or the pumpkin-spice preserves.
- The 8.5-ounce jar offers a middle-ground format among these picks.
Cons:- Its sweet-tart profile may clash with some dishes or personal preferences.
- Less suited to shoppers who want a conventional sweet spread for toast and pastries.
- The supplied product details do not state dietary certifications or a full ingredient list.
Best for: People building a holiday cheese board or serving seasoned meats and spicy dishes who want a fruit condiment with herbs and spices.
Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for a simple sweet breakfast jam, a pumpkin-spice flavor, or confirmed dietary certifications not listed here.
- Brand:Stonewall Kitchen
- Product type:Apple cranberry chutney
- Net weight:8.5 ounces
- Fruit:Apples and cranberries
- Flavor additions:Herbs and spices
- Suggested pairings:Spicy meals, seasoned meats, crackers, and cheese
Our verdict“I recommend this chutney for buyers who want a holiday condiment for cheese and savory food, rather than a jam-led brunch spread.”
Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 4 oz
This 4-ounce jar has the same stated Holiday Jam profile as the larger Stonewall Kitchen version: pears, cranberries, raspberries, and a hint of orange liqueur. Its role is different because of its size. I would choose it when the goal is a small hostess gift, a compact holiday-table addition, or a chance to offer a distinctive flavor without opening a larger jar. Its red color also gives a festive visual accent alongside bread, pastries, or a brunch setting.
Against the 12.5-ounce jar of the same jam, there is little reason to select this option for a larger household or gathering unless a small format is specifically useful. The larger jar carries the same flavor direction with substantially more spread to serve. Compared with Bonne Maman’s two 13-ounce jars, this is a much smaller commitment and a very different flavor: berry-and-pear brightness instead of warm pumpkin spice. It also cannot take the chutney’s place as the lineup’s most clearly savory choice.
The compact size is both its strength and its limit. At 4 ounces, it may not be enough for a crowd, and the small jar is less practical as the only spread for a holiday brunch. The orange liqueur remains a dietary consideration, just as it is in the larger Holiday Jam; choosing a smaller jar does not remove that ingredient concern. I place this last in the overall ranking because it is more specialized by serving size, not because the described flavor is inferior. For a gift or a small tasting portion, that specialization can be exactly what a buyer needs.
Pros:- The same distinctive fruit blend as the larger Holiday Jam comes in a compact format.
- Red color suits a festive brunch presentation or small gift.
- A manageable option for a small household or a taste of the holiday flavor.
- Offers a different flavor direction from the pumpkin-spice preserves and savory chutney.
Cons:- The 4-ounce jar may not be enough for a large gathering.
- The 12.5-ounce version is the more practical choice when serving multiple guests.
- Contains orange liqueur, which may not suit every dietary preference.
Best for: Gift-givers and shoppers who want a compact jar of festive pear, cranberry, raspberry, and orange liqueur jam for a small table or tasting.
Not ideal for: Hosts feeding a large gathering, shoppers seeking the most spread per jar, or anyone avoiding orange liqueur.
- Brand:Stonewall Kitchen
- Product type:Holiday jam
- Flavor blend:Pears, cranberries, raspberries, and orange liqueur
- Net weight:4 ounces
- Container:Jar
- Color:Red
- Suggested use:Breakfast, toast, or holiday presentation
Our verdict“I would choose the 4-ounce Holiday Jam for a small gift or tasting, but the 12.5-ounce jar is the better choice for hosting.”

How We Picked
I ranked these spreads around the occasions implied by the holiday-spread search: brunch, toast, cheese boards, meals, and gifting. Each product has a different job, so I did not treat a preserve, jam, and chutney as interchangeable. The 12.5-ounce Holiday Jam earns the lead because it combines a distinctive festive fruit blend with the largest listed single-jar format, a practical advantage when several guests will share it. The Bonne Maman two-jar pack follows for shoppers who want a recognizable warm-spice profile and more than one jar, though pumpkin spice is a narrower flavor choice.
I also weighed serving versatility and the information available about ingredients and dietary attributes. The chutney ranks highly for savory pairings because its apples, cranberries, herbs, and spices suggest uses beyond sweet breakfast spreads. The 4-ounce Holiday Jam is last not because its flavor is weaker than the larger jar’s, but because the same blend arrives in a much smaller format, making it less practical for hosting. I noted the stated orange liqueur in both jam options, the sugar-containing nature of fruit spreads, and the seasonal flavor boundaries where supplied. I did not infer ingredient, dietary, or storage details that were not provided.
These rankings are meant to make the choice visible: sharing capacity favors the large jar, warm seasonal character favors Bonne Maman, and savory flexibility favors the chutney. The right pick changes with the menu and the number of people at the table.
| holiday spread | Product type |
|---|---|
| Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam | Holiday jam |
| Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Pres | — |
| Stonewall Kitchen Apple Cranbe | Apple cranberry chutney |
| Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam | Holiday jam |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Holiday Spreads
I would choose a holiday spread by matching its flavor and serving format to the food around it. These four options cover three different jobs: sweet breakfast spreads, a compact festive gift, and a savory fruit condiment. A quick check of guest preferences and menu can narrow the choice faster than the holiday label alone.
Match sweetness and spice to the menu
For toast, pastries, or a sweet brunch table, the two Holiday Jams and Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves are the natural starting points. The Stonewall Kitchen blend pairs pears and berries with a hint of orange liqueur, giving it a brighter, fruit-forward character. Bonne Maman instead places pumpkin and warm spices at the center. I would choose between them based on whether guests prefer tart berries and citrus or a familiar spiced seasonal flavor.
The chutney belongs in a different lane. Apples, cranberries, herbs, and spices give it a sweet-tart character intended for crackers, cheese, seasoned meats, and spicy meals. That does not make it unsuitable for a holiday table; it makes it better suited to the savory side. If one jar must cover both toast and a meat course, none of these is equally strong at every task, so I would prioritize the meal where the spread matters most.
Choose jar size for the number of servings
Format changes how useful a flavor is at a gathering. The 12.5-ounce Holiday Jam is the strongest single-jar choice for sharing, while the 4-ounce version is better for a small gift, a tasting, or a modest table. Bonne Maman arrives as two 13-ounce jars, which means buyers can split the jars between occasions or keep one unopened until needed. The chutney’s 8.5-ounce jar falls between the compact jam and larger formats.
Do not assume two jars are automatically better for every host. A pair of preserves can be convenient if you want a spare or separate serving jars, while a single larger jar may be simpler to put out at one brunch. For a crowd, I would avoid relying on the 4-ounce jar as the only spread; for a small household or gift basket, its compact size is part of the appeal.
Check ingredient and dietary preferences
The supplied product information lists orange liqueur in both Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam formats. That detail may matter to guests who avoid alcohol or have a dietary preference that makes the ingredient unsuitable. If the table includes several guests, I would label the jar clearly or select another option. The pumpkin-spice preserves list fruit, sugar, pectin, and lemon juice and are described as Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and certified kosher.
All four spreads are fruit preparations with a sweet or sweet-tart profile, and the pumpkin-spice preserves explicitly contain sugar. The chutney details supplied here do not identify dietary certifications or provide a full ingredient list. If a specific dietary restriction is central to the purchase, I would check the current package details before serving rather than assume that a product fits based on its category or flavor.
Decide whether versatility or a clear holiday identity matters more
A strongly seasonal flavor can make a holiday meal feel intentional, but it may not be the spread you reach for after the occasion. Pumpkin spice has a clear autumn-and-holiday identity; the Holiday Jam similarly leans into festive fruit and orange liqueur. The chutney’s listed pairings include everyday foods such as crackers and cheese as well as seasoned meals, giving it a more savory use case beyond breakfast.
For a gift, I would favor format as much as flavor: the 4-ounce Holiday Jam is compact, while the larger Holiday Jam is better suited to a host who plans to serve it. For ongoing use, think about how often your household serves toast, cheese, or meat with a fruit accompaniment. Choosing a jar that fits those habits reduces the chance that a distinctive seasonal spread sits unused.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which spread is the best choice for a holiday brunch?
I would choose the 12.5-ounce Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam for a group brunch because its pear, cranberry, raspberry, and orange liqueur blend comes in the largest listed single jar. For a warm-spice option, Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves offer two 13-ounce jars, which can suit a table where pumpkin spice is a better flavor match. The smaller 4-ounce jam works better as a tasting or gift than as the only spread for several guests.
Which option works best with cheese or savory food?
The Stonewall Kitchen Apple Cranberry Chutney is the most direct fit for cheese and savory meals. Its apples and cranberries are combined with herbs and spices, and the listed pairings include crackers, cheese, seasoned meats, and spicy dishes. The Holiday Jams are more clearly positioned as fruit-forward breakfast spreads, while Bonne Maman is distinguished by pumpkin and warm spices.
What is the difference between the two Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jams?
The supplied descriptions give both versions the same blend of pears, cranberries, raspberries, and a hint of orange liqueur. Their clearest difference is jar size: one is 4 ounces and the other is 12.5 ounces. I would choose the small jar for a compact gift or tasting and the larger jar when serving a brunch or sharing with more people. Both include orange liqueur, which may not suit every guest.
Which spread has the clearest dietary information?
Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves have the most specific dietary attributes listed here: they are identified as Non-GMO Project Verified, gluten-free, and certified kosher. The provided details also list fruit, sugar, pectin, and lemon juice. The supplied information for the chutney does not state comparable certifications, and both Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam listings specify orange liqueur. Buyers managing a dietary restriction should check the current package information before serving.
Which spread should I buy as a small hostess gift?
The 4-ounce Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam is the most compact option and its red color and festive fruit blend suit a small gift or tasting. If the recipient is likely to serve a larger group, the 12.5-ounce version is more practical. I would avoid either Holiday Jam if the recipient avoids orange liqueur, and choose the pumpkin-spice preserves instead only if warm seasonal flavors are likely to appeal.
Conclusion
My recommendation depends on the job the jar needs to do. For a host serving several people, I would choose Stonewall Kitchen Holiday Jam, 12.5 Ounces for its shareable size and bright pear-and-berry blend, provided orange liqueur suits the guests. For a buyer who wants warm spice and two jars, Bonne Maman Pumpkin Spice Preserves are the stronger match. Choose Apple Cranberry Chutney for crackers, cheese, meats, or spicy meals; its savory role sets it apart from the breakfast-leaning options. If the priority is a small hostess gift or a taste rather than a full table serving, the 4-ounce Holiday Jam makes the most sense. Matching flavor, serving size, and guest preferences is the clearest way to pick the right holiday spread.




