The best store-bought apple pie depends on whether you want a handheld snack or a full dessert to serve warm. I’d put Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie first for a shareable, classic pie format, while Tastykake French Apple Pies suit snackers who want a distinct topping and Hostess Single-Serve Apple Pies work well for stocking individual portions. The main tradeoffs are full-size versus portable, apple-only packs versus mixed flavors, and familiar convenience versus a more dessert-like presentation. Pack counts and pie sizes also vary, so the largest bundle may not suit every household. Continue reading for the full breakdown and a guide to choosing the format that fits your plans.
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie is the roundup’s full-dessert choice; the snack pies are more practical when individual portions matter.
- Tastykake French Apple Pies stand apart by format, giving buyers an alternative to the standard handheld pie rather than just another pack size.
- Hostess and JJ’s Bakery appear in several pack configurations, so shoppers can prioritize portion count and pantry convenience within familiar snack-pie styles.
- Tastykake Variety Baked Pies trade an all-apple pack for cherry, blueberry, and lemon options, making them more useful for mixed tastes than for stocking up on apple alone.
- The two frozen full-pie listings serve a different occasion from the individually wrapped options; compare pie size and serving plans before choosing between them.
| JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies, 4 oz Each, Pack of 6 |  | Best for Dietary Flexibility | Flavor: Apple | Weight per pie: 4 oz | Pack size: 6 pies | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Hostess Snack Size Apple Fruit Pies, 12 Count |  | Best for Sharing on the Go | Flavor: Apple | Count: 12 pies | Size: Snack size | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Entenmann’s Minis Apple Snack Pies, 6 Count, 12 oz |  | Best for Cinnamon-Spiced Minis | Flavor: Apple | Count: 6 pies | Package weight: 12 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Hostess Single-Serve Apple Pies, 16 Count |  | Best for Maximum Portion Count | Flavor: Apple | Quantity: 16 pies | Serving format: Single-serve | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Hostess Apple Fruit Pie, 4.25 oz, 8 Count |  | Best for a Fuller Individual Snack | Flavor: Apple | Product type: Fruit pie | Weight per pie: 4.25 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Tastykake French Apple Pies, Pack of 6 |  | Best for Simple On-the-Go Snacking | Flavor: French apple | Quantity: 6 pies | Format: Individual pies | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| JJ’s Bakery Apple Pie Snack Pies, 4 oz, 12-Pack |  | Best for Sharing and Dietary Flexibility | Flavor: Apple pie | Package quantity: 12 pies | Serving size: 4 oz each | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Tastykake Baked Apple Pies, 6 Pack |  | Best for a Sweet-Tart Filling | Brand: Tastykake | Flavor: Apple | Quantity: 6 pies | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Tastykake French Apple Pie, 4 oz (Pack of 6) |  | Best for a Clearly Sized Portion | Flavor: French apple | Weight: 4 oz per pie | Pack size: 6 pies | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Tastykake Variety Baked Pies, Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, and Apple, 4 Pack |  | Best for Mixed-Flavor Households | Flavors: Cherry, blueberry, lemon, and apple | Pack size: 4 pies | Apple portions: 1 pie | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies, 12 Pack |  | Best for Sharing and Stocking Up | Flavor: Apple | Package quantity: 12 pies | Package weight: 48 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie, 37 oz (Frozen) |  | Best Classic Frozen Pie | Weight: 37 oz | Product type: Frozen apple pie | Crust: Original flaky crust | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frozen Apple Pie, 26 oz |  | Best for a Cinnamon-Forward Ingredient Cue | Weight: 26 oz | Product type: Frozen apple pie | Ingredients: Apples, cinnamon, flaky pie crust | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| store-bought apple pie | Flavor |
|---|---|
| JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies | Apple |
| Hostess Snack Size Apple Fruit | Apple |
| Entenmann’s Minis Apple Snack | Apple |
| Hostess Single-Serve Apple Pie | Apple |
| Hostess Apple Fruit Pie | Apple |
| Tastykake French Apple Pies | French apple |
| JJ’s Bakery Apple Pie Snack Pi | Apple pie |
| Tastykake Baked Apple Pies | Apple |
| Tastykake French Apple Pie | French apple |
| Tastykake Variety Baked Pies | — |
| JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies | Apple |
| Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Cr | — |
| Frozen Apple Pie | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies, 4 oz Each, Pack of 6
JJ’s Bakery suits buyers who want individual apple pies with clear dietary details rather than a large dessert to slice. Each pie is 4 oz, so it works as a self-contained snack or a small dessert portion, and the six-pack is easier to divide than a full-size frozen pie such as Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie. Its nut-free and kosher parve descriptions give some households useful screening information, though they do not replace checking the package for allergy needs. Compared with Entenmann’s Minis, this listing does not specify cinnamon-spiced filling or individual wrapping, so it offers less detail about flavor and packaging. The tradeoff is a modest pack size and a snack-pie format, not a sliceable centerpiece.
Pros:- Six individually portioned 4 oz pies are easy to hand out
- Described as nut-free
- Kosher parve designation is provided
- Apple flavor keeps the choice straightforward
Cons:- Six pies may not stretch as far as the 12-count JJ’s Bakery pack
- No filling texture, crust, or ingredient details are provided
- Snack-pie format is less suited to a shared dessert presentation
Best for: Households seeking individually sized apple pies with nut-free and kosher parve information listed
Not ideal for: Anyone serving a traditional pie by the slice or needing detailed ingredient and allergen information before purchase
- Flavor:Apple
- Weight per pie:4 oz
- Pack size:6 pies
- Dietary information:Described as nut-free
- Certification:Kosher parve
- Product format:Individually portioned snack pies
Our verdict“Choose this six-pack if dietary labeling and ready-to-serve portions matter more than a full-size pie or a larger count.”
Hostess Snack Size Apple Fruit Pies, 12 Count
The strongest case for these Hostess pies is quantity and portability: twelve snack-size portions make it simple to pack treats for a group without cutting or serving a whole pie. That count beats the six-pie JJ’s Bakery and Entenmann’s Minis packs when you need more individual servings in one box. The listing describes a sweet apple filling, but gives little else about crust, ingredients, or dietary suitability, so buyers who need those details should favor a product with more specific information, such as JJ’s Bakery’s nut-free and kosher parve listing. These are best understood as convenient snack pies, not as a traditional apple pie for a table dessert. The larger count is useful, but the lack of detail makes it harder to judge flavor and fit in advance.
Pros:- Twelve portions suit group distribution
- Snack-size format is convenient to carry
- Apple filling is described as sweet
- No slicing or serving utensils are needed
Cons:- No crust or filling-texture details are provided
- Ingredient and dietary information is not included in the supplied listing
- Snack-size format is not a substitute for a traditional pie centerpiece
Best for: People packing individual apple treats for a group, shared break room, or on-the-go snacks
Not ideal for: Buyers who need ingredient, allergen, or dietary-certification details or want a sliceable pie for dessert
- Flavor:Apple
- Count:12 pies
- Size:Snack size
- Filling description:Sweet apple flavor
- Product format:Individual snack pies
- Brand:Hostess
Our verdict“Pick this pack when you need many portable apple snacks and can shop without detailed ingredient or dietary information.”
Entenmann’s Minis Apple Snack Pies, 6 Count, 12 oz
Entenmann’s gives buyers the most specific flavor picture among these small packs: its minis have cinnamon-spiced apple filling and a flaky crust. That makes it a better fit for someone who wants a recognizable spiced-pie profile than Hostess Snack Size Apple Fruit Pies, whose listing describes sweet apple flavor but says little about the crust. The six pies are individually wrapped, a practical advantage for packing snacks or saving portions, and the OU Parve certification is stated. The tradeoff is a smaller count than the 12-piece Hostess options, and the product is explicitly a sweet snack rather than a less-sweet dessert. Its 12 oz package weight works out to 2 oz per pie, so these minis are smaller than JJ’s Bakery’s 4 oz pies.
Pros:- Cinnamon-spiced apple filling offers a more defined flavor profile
- Flaky crust is specified
- Individually wrapped for portioning and packing
- Kosher certified (OU Parve)
Cons:- Six-count pack provides fewer servings than Hostess’s 12-count option
- At 12 oz for six pies, each is smaller than JJ’s Bakery’s 4 oz pies
- Sweet snack may not suit buyers limiting sugar
Best for: Buyers who want individually wrapped, smaller apple pies with cinnamon-spiced filling and stated kosher certification
Not ideal for: Those wanting a larger 4 oz snack pie, a bigger pack, or a less-sweet option
- Flavor:Apple
- Count:6 pies
- Package weight:12 oz
- Approximate weight per pie:2 oz, based on package weight divided by count
- Packaging:Individually wrapped
- Filling:Cinnamon-spiced apple
- Crust:Flaky
- Certification:Kosher (OU Parve)
Our verdict“Choose these minis for wrapped, cinnamon-spiced portions; skip them if you want a larger pie or more servings per pack.”
Hostess Single-Serve Apple Pies, 16 Count
This Hostess pack is the lineup’s clearest choice when the priority is having 16 individual pies on hand. That count exceeds the 12-piece Hostess Snack Size Apple Fruit Pies, making it more suitable for a larger gathering or a stash intended to last across multiple snack breaks. The listing confirms the apple flavor and single-serve format, but provides no further product details. By comparison, Entenmann’s Minis specifies cinnamon-spiced filling, flaky crust, individual wrapping, and kosher certification; buyers who care about those qualities have more to go on with Entenmann’s. Here, the high count comes with a real information gap: size, ingredients, packaging, and dietary details are not supplied. It makes the most sense when portion count matters more than selecting a pie by its flavor or dietary profile.
Pros:- Sixteen individual pies offer the largest stated count among these five products
- Apple flavor is identified
- Single-serve portions require no slicing
- Useful for distributing individual snacks
Cons:- Listing provides no size or weight information
- Ingredient and dietary details are not supplied
- Crust and filling characteristics are unspecified
Best for: Organizers or households prioritizing a high number of individual apple pie servings
Not ideal for: Buyers who need stated pie size, ingredient or allergen details, dietary certification, or a defined crust and filling style
- Flavor:Apple
- Quantity:16 pies
- Serving format:Single-serve
- Brand:Hostess
- Product type:Individual apple pies
- Pie size:Not provided
- Ingredient details:Not provided
Our verdict“Choose this pack for its 16 portions, but select a more fully described option if flavor details or dietary information guide your purchase.”
Hostess Apple Fruit Pie, 4.25 oz, 8 Count
At 4.25 oz per pie, this Hostess pack offers a more substantial individual portion than Entenmann’s Minis, which average 2 oz each based on the stated package weight and count. That makes it a stronger fit when a snack pie is meant to stand on its own, while the eight-count remains easier to manage than the 12- and 16-piece Hostess packs. The listing also identifies apple fruit filling and states 0 g of trans fat. Those details do not describe the pie’s full nutrition or ingredient profile, so they should not be read as a broader health claim. Compared with JJ’s Bakery’s 4 oz pies, these are slightly larger by listed weight, but the supplied data does not offer JJ’s dietary details or this product’s texture and spice notes. The tradeoff is a portable, sweet snack rather than a classic pie for slicing.
Pros:- 4.25 oz per pie makes for a substantial individual serving
- Eight-count pack offers a middle ground between six- and 12-piece options
- Apple fruit filling is identified
- Listing states 0 g of trans fat
Cons:- Sweet snack-pie format may not suit those limiting sweet foods
- No crust or filling-texture details are supplied
- The stated trans-fat figure does not provide a full nutrition profile
Best for: Snack-pie buyers who prefer a larger single portion and want a moderate eight-pie pack
Not ideal for: People seeking a shareable full-size pie, detailed dietary information, or a less-sweet dessert
- Flavor:Apple
- Product type:Fruit pie
- Weight per pie:4.25 oz
- Count:8 pies
- Trans fat:0 g, as stated in the product data
- Brand:Hostess
Our verdict“Pick this option for larger portable portions in an eight-pack, not for a traditional pie or a detailed nutrition profile.”
Tastykake French Apple Pies, Pack of 6
Six individual French apple pies make this a straightforward choice for keeping a portable sweet snack on hand. Unlike the JJ’s Bakery Apple Pie Snack Pies, 12-Pack, this package has fewer portions, so it suits a smaller household or someone who does not want to store a larger multipack. The French apple style gives it a pastry-snack role rather than the sit-down dessert format of a full-size pie. The tradeoff is limited detail: the supplied product information does not specify pie weight, ingredients, or preparation, making it harder to compare portion size and filling. Choose it for convenience and a defined six-pie pack, not for a particular nutrition profile or a large gathering.
Pros:- Six individual pies offer portioned convenience
- Portable format suits on-the-go snacking
- French apple flavor gives it a distinct pastry-snack style
Cons:- Pack has fewer pies than the 12-count JJ’s Bakery option
- No pie weight or ingredient details are provided
- Product information does not describe heating or serving guidance
Best for: People who want a small stash of individually portioned apple pastries for commutes, lunchboxes, or occasional snacks
Not ideal for: Households needing a dozen portions or shoppers who need verified details about pie size and ingredients
- Flavor:French apple
- Quantity:6 pies
- Format:Individual pies
- Use:On-the-go snacking
- Product type:French apple pies
- Pack format:Pack of 6
Our verdict“Choose this six-pack for portable French apple snacks, but pick JJ’s Bakery’s 12-pack if you need more individually wrapped portions.”
JJ’s Bakery Apple Pie Snack Pies, 4 oz, 12-Pack
Twelve individually wrapped 4-ounce pies give this option a clear advantage for stocking lunchboxes, office drawers, or party tables. Compared with Tastykake French Apple Pies, Pack of 6, it offers twice as many individually portioned snacks and more explicit dietary details: the pies are dairy free and Kosher Parve, and the facility is described as peanut- and tree nut-free. Those details may help shoppers plan for particular dietary needs, though they do not replace checking the package for personal allergen requirements. The pies can be eaten as packaged or warmed according to package directions, adding flexibility that the supplied Tastykake six-pack information does not mention. The tradeoff is that the bulkier 12-count pack may be more than a solo snack buyer needs.
Pros:- Twelve individually wrapped pies suit group use and lunchboxes
- Each pie has a specified 4-ounce serving size
- Identified as dairy free and Kosher Parve
- Can be eaten as packaged or warmed according to package directions
Cons:- A dozen pies may be excessive for occasional solo snacking
- Snack-pie portions are not a replacement for a shared full-size pie
- Facility information alone may not satisfy every shopper’s allergen requirements
Best for: Families, office snack organizers, and shoppers seeking dairy-free, Kosher Parve individually wrapped apple pies
Not ideal for: Buyers who want only a few portions, need a full-size apple pie, or require allergen assurances beyond the stated facility information
- Flavor:Apple pie
- Package quantity:12 pies
- Serving size:4 oz each
- Packaging:Individually wrapped
- Dietary details:Dairy free; Kosher Parve
- Facility:Made in a peanut- and tree nut-free facility
- Preparation:Enjoy as packaged or warm according to package directions
Our verdict“Pick this pack when you want many individually wrapped portions and the stated dietary attributes; choose Tastykake’s six-pack for a smaller supply.”
Tastykake Baked Apple Pies, 6 Pack
The defining appeal here is the described contrast between a flaky crust and sweet-tart apple filling, which gives this six-pack a sharper flavor profile than the straightforward French apple snacks from Tastykake French Apple Pies, Pack of 6. Its individually packaged portions fit snacks, lunchboxes, or a quick dessert without asking buyers to slice a full pie. That convenience comes with a notable information gap: the supplied copy inconsistently refers to the filling as lemon, even though the product is titled and otherwise described as apple. I would treat the apple description as the intended flavor, but shoppers who need dependable ingredient or flavor confirmation should check the packaging before buying. The product data also does not state the weight of each pie, limiting portion comparisons with JJ’s 4-ounce snack pies.
Pros:- Individually packaged pies are convenient for snacks and lunchboxes
- Flaky crust gives the pastry a defined texture
- Sweet-tart filling offers a flavor contrast
- Six pies provide a compact multipack
Cons:- Product information inconsistently describes the filling as lemon
- Individual pie weight is not specified
- No dietary details or heating directions are provided
Best for: Snackers who prefer a portable apple pastry with a stated sweet-tart filling and flaky crust
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need unambiguous flavor details, a specified portion weight, or a full-size dessert pie
- Brand:Tastykake
- Flavor:Apple
- Quantity:6 pies
- Packaging:Individually packaged
- Crust:Flaky
- Filling description:Sweet-tart apple; product copy also inconsistently says lemon
Our verdict“Choose this for individually packed sweet-tart apple snacks if you are comfortable verifying the flavor description on the package.”
Tastykake French Apple Pie, 4 oz (Pack of 6)
With six pre-baked, individually wrapped 4-ounce pies, this Tastykake option gives portion-focused shoppers more concrete information than the similarly sized-in-concept Tastykake Baked Apple Pies, 6 Pack, whose supplied details do not state individual weight. Its description also specifies real apple fruit filling and a flaky pastry crust, helping set expectations for a hand-held sweet rather than a traditional sliced pie. That clarity is useful, but the product is still a sweet dessert and the listing itself warns it may not suit shoppers seeking a less sugary snack. Compared with JJ’s Bakery Apple Pie Snack Pies, 4 oz, 12-Pack, the 4-ounce size matches while the six-count pack is easier to choose when a dozen portions would be excessive.
Pros:- Each pie is specified as 4 ounces
- Individually wrapped for storage and portability
- Description identifies real apple fruit filling
- Pre-baked and ready to enjoy
Cons:- Sweet dessert profile may not suit people seeking a less sugary snack
- Six portions provide fewer servings than JJ’s Bakery’s 12-pack
- Hand-held pies do not serve as a traditional shared pie
Best for: Buyers who want a specified 4-ounce apple pie portion for a snack or individual dessert
Not ideal for: Shoppers limiting sweet pastries, seeking a large pie to serve by the slice, or needing more than six portions
- Flavor:French apple
- Weight:4 oz per pie
- Pack size:6 pies
- Filling:Real apple fruit
- Packaging:Individually wrapped
- Preparation:Pre-baked
- Crust:Flaky pastry
Our verdict“Pick this six-pack for clearly sized, ready-to-eat apple pie portions; choose JJ’s Bakery’s 12-pack when you need the same stated size in greater quantity.”
Tastykake Variety Baked Pies, Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, and Apple, 4 Pack
This is the lineup’s clearest pick for people who want more than apple in the box: the four individually packaged pies cover cherry, blueberry, lemon, and apple. That variety separates it from Tastykake French Apple Pie, 4 oz (Pack of 6), which keeps every portion focused on apple and provides a larger count. Here, the tradeoff is explicit: there is only one apple pie, so dedicated apple-pie fans get less of the flavor they came for. The pies are described as made with real fruit and flaky crust, and their individual wrapping supports grab-and-go use. Since the product information does not give individual weights or identify how the four flavors are distributed beyond one of each, this is best viewed as a tasting assortment, not an apple-pie stock-up.
Pros:- Includes four distinct fruit flavors
- Individually packaged for portable snacks
- Description identifies real fruit in the pies
- Flaky crust is specified
Cons:- Only one of the four pies is apple
- Individual pie weights are not provided
- Sweet baked pastries may not suit shoppers avoiding dessert-style snacks
Best for: Households or snackers who enjoy several fruit-pie flavors and want one apple option among them
Not ideal for: Apple-pie loyalists who want several apple portions or buyers who need specified pie weights
- Flavors:Cherry, blueberry, lemon, and apple
- Pack size:4 pies
- Apple portions:1 pie
- Fruit:Made with real fruit
- Packaging:Individually packaged
- Crust:Flaky
- Use:Snack, dessert, or on-the-go
Our verdict“Choose this assortment for flavor variety, but select Tastykake’s six-pack French apple pies if apple is the main priority.”
JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies, 12 Pack
JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies suit households that want individual portions ready to grab, rather than a single pie to thaw and slice. The 12-count package gives you twice as many pies as JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies, 4 oz Each, Pack of 6, while keeping the same listed 4-ounce size per pie. That makes this pack a practical fit for group snacks or storing portions for later. The tradeoff is format: these are snack pies, not a traditional whole pie with slices to serve after dinner. The product details also do not specify ingredients, crust style, or heating directions, so buyers seeking those details may prefer Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie, which clearly identifies its crust and use of butter.
Pros:- 12 individually portioned pies make sharing and packing snacks straightforward
- Each pie weighs 4 oz, giving a defined single-serving size
- 48 oz total package weight provides a larger supply than the six-count JJ’s Bakery pack
Cons:- Snack-pie format does not provide traditional slices for serving a group
- Available product details do not specify crust style or ingredients
- No heating or preparation instructions are provided in the listed specs
Best for: Households, lunch packers, or event hosts who want 12 individually portioned apple snacks rather than a pie to slice.
Not ideal for: Buyers planning a traditional sit-down pie dessert, or anyone who needs ingredient and allergen details beyond the listed apple flavor.
- Flavor:Apple
- Package quantity:12 pies
- Package weight:48 oz
- Individual pie weight:4 oz
- Product format:Snack pies
- Serving format:Individual portions
Our verdict“Choose this pack for a ready-to-share supply of single-serve apple pies, not for a classic whole-pie dessert.”
Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie, 37 oz (Frozen)
For a more traditional dessert, Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie is the strongest fit in this group: it is a 37-ounce frozen pie with an original flaky crust made with real butter. Its whole-pie format is better suited to serving slices than the individually wrapped snack pies from JJ’s Bakery, though it calls for more planning because it is frozen rather than ready to grab as a snack. The listed absence of artificial flavors and sweeteners is a useful distinction for shoppers checking those ingredients. Compared with the 26-ounce Frozen Apple Pie, it offers a larger stated weight and names butter in the crust, but the supplied details do not list its apple or spice ingredients. Choose it for a familiar pie-style serving; skip it if you need single portions or fuller ingredient information.
Pros:- Whole-pie format suits serving slices for dessert
- Original flaky crust is made with real butter
- Contains no artificial flavors or artificial sweeteners
- At 37 oz, it is larger by listed weight than the 26 oz Frozen Apple Pie
Cons:- Frozen format requires planning before serving
- Less convenient for portioning into grab-and-go snacks than JJ’s Bakery’s 12-pack
- The supplied product details do not list apple or spice ingredients
Best for: Shoppers who want a full-size frozen apple pie for serving slices at a family meal or gathering.
Not ideal for: People seeking portable single-serve snacks, or shoppers who need listed details about apple varieties, spices, or allergens.
- Weight:37 oz
- Product type:Frozen apple pie
- Crust:Original flaky crust
- Crust ingredient:Real butter
- Artificial flavors:None
- Artificial sweeteners:None
- Serving format:Whole pie
Our verdict“Pick Mrs. Smith’s when you want a larger, traditional frozen pie with a butter-made flaky crust rather than individually portioned snacks.”
Frozen Apple Pie, 26 oz
Frozen Apple Pie, 26 oz makes its apple-and-spice profile clear: the listed ingredients include real apples and a touch of cinnamon, wrapped in a flaky crust. That ingredient detail gives it a different appeal from Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie, whose supplied description highlights butter and the absence of artificial flavors and sweeteners instead. At 26 oz, this pie is also smaller by listed weight than Mrs. Smith’s 37-ounce option, which may suit buyers who want a more modest whole pie. The tradeoff is that the product information does not specify whether the crust contains butter or provide claims about artificial ingredients. It also lists egg, milk, soy, and wheat, so it is not suitable for shoppers avoiding those allergens.
Pros:- Real apples are listed among the ingredients
- A touch of cinnamon provides a clear apple-pie spice cue
- Flaky crust offers a pie-style alternative to snack-sized products
Cons:- At 26 oz, it is smaller by listed weight than Mrs. Smith’s 37 oz pie
- Contains egg, milk, soy, and wheat
- The supplied details do not identify butter in the crust or address artificial ingredients
Best for: Shoppers who want a frozen whole pie with apples and cinnamon explicitly listed and do not need a larger pie.
Not ideal for: Anyone avoiding egg, milk, soy, or wheat, or buyers seeking stated butter-crust or artificial-ingredient details.
- Weight:26 oz
- Product type:Frozen apple pie
- Ingredients:Apples, cinnamon, flaky pie crust
- Crust:Flaky pie crust
- Allergen:Egg
- Allergen:Milk
- Allergen:Soy
- Allergen:Wheat
Our verdict“Choose this smaller frozen pie if listed apples and cinnamon matter more to you than the extra weight and ingredient claims of Mrs. Smith’s.”
How We Picked
I compared the 13 listings around the decisions shoppers face when choosing store-bought apple pie: serving format, portion size, pack count, flavor focus, and intended occasion. A full frozen pie ranks ahead for a sit-down dessert, while portable multipacks make more sense for lunchboxes, quick snacks, or keeping individual portions on hand. I also treated French-style and variety packs as distinct choices rather than assuming every apple pie buyer wants the same crust or an apple-only bundle.
The order reflects usefulness for the widest range of apple-pie occasions first, followed by narrower strengths such as portability, pack configuration, or flavor variety. Where two listings share a brand and a similar product type, I distinguish them by their listed size and count instead of implying a taste difference that the product details do not establish. The rankings are based on the supplied product information, not first-hand tasting; shoppers should check current package details for ingredients, storage directions, and exact contents.
| store-bought apple pie | Flavor |
|---|---|
| JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies | Apple |
| Hostess Snack Size Apple Fruit | Apple |
| Entenmann’s Minis Apple Snack | Apple |
| Hostess Single-Serve Apple Pie | Apple |
| Hostess Apple Fruit Pie | Apple |
| Tastykake French Apple Pies | French apple |
| JJ’s Bakery Apple Pie Snack Pi | Apple pie |
| Tastykake Baked Apple Pies | Apple |
| Tastykake French Apple Pie | French apple |
| Tastykake Variety Baked Pies | — |
| JJ’s Bakery Apple Snack Pies | Apple |
| Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Cr | — |
| Frozen Apple Pie | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Store-bought Apple Pies
Before choosing a box, decide how and when the pie will be served. The category spans single portions, multipacks, mixed-flavor assortments, and frozen full pies, and those formats solve different problems. These checks can help you avoid buying more pie than you can use or choosing a snack pack when you wanted a dessert centerpiece.
Choose Between a Handheld Pie and a Full Dessert
Start with the occasion, not the package count. A handheld pie is easier to portion for snacks or packed lunches, while a full pie gives you a more familiar dessert to slice and share. A large multipack can look like the convenient choice, but it may be awkward if you only need dessert for one meal. Frozen pies also call for freezer space and time to prepare, so check the storage and baking directions before buying. If you want both portability and a plated dessert, buying a snack pack will not fully replace a full-size pie.
Compare Portion Counts With Household Habits
Pack count is useful only when it matches how quickly your household eats individually wrapped pies. A higher count may help when several people want a snack, but can leave extra portions on hand if apple pie is an occasional treat. Check both the number of pies and the stated weight, since count alone does not tell you how substantial each portion is. For school or work snacks, individual packaging may matter more than total quantity. Avoid choosing a multipack solely because it contains more pieces; consider storage space and the time you have to use it.
Decide Whether Apple Must Be the Only Flavor
An apple-only pack is the straightforward choice when you already know everyone wants apple. A variety box can reduce the risk of leftover flavors if your household has different preferences, but it gives you fewer apple pies per pack. Think about the event too: mixed flavors can offer guests a choice, whereas an apple-focused bundle is simpler for a dedicated apple-pie craving. Check which flavors are listed rather than assuming the assortment can be customized. If apple is the main reason for your purchase, a mixed pack may be less practical even if it offers more variety overall.
Look Past the Word “Apple” to the Pie Style
Not every store-bought apple pie is meant to deliver the same eating experience. Snack pies emphasize portability, while French-style versions offer a different presentation from standard handheld varieties. A full pie is closer to the familiar sliced-dessert format, but it requires serving and preparation planning. Read the product name and package details for cues about the crust style and format instead of treating every apple filling as interchangeable. If crust texture is your priority, product titles alone may not answer every question, so review the current package information before ordering.
Plan for Storage and Preparation
Frozen pies and shelf-stable-style snack multipacks have different storage demands, so make room before you buy. A frozen pie can suit planned dessert occasions, but it is less convenient when you need something ready to eat immediately. Snack pies are easier to portion, though the package still needs to be stored according to its label. Check preparation directions, especially if you expect to serve a pie warm or need dessert at a specific time. A common mistake is choosing by size alone and discovering that the required freezer space or preparation time does not fit your routine.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I buy a frozen apple pie or individually wrapped snack pies?
Choose a frozen pie when you want a dessert to slice and serve, and when you have freezer space and time to follow its preparation directions. Individually portioned snack pies are more convenient for grab-and-go eating or serving several people without slicing. The formats are not direct substitutes: a snack pie is easy to portion but less suited to a shared dessert table, while a full pie takes more planning. Match the package to the occasion you have in mind. If you need both formats regularly, keeping separate options may make more sense than expecting one to cover every use.
How do I choose between the Hostess and JJ’s Bakery multipacks?
Compare the specific listings by stated count, individual size, and the product format you prefer rather than assuming brand alone determines the better fit. The roundup includes several Hostess and JJ’s Bakery configurations, including different package counts, so the quantity you need can be a practical deciding factor. Check current packaging for ingredient and storage details that matter to your household. If you are buying for a small household, a lower-count pack may be easier to use; a larger pack may suit frequent snacking. Product labels are the best source for confirming the exact contents of the box you are ordering.
Is a variety pack a good choice if I mainly want apple pie?
A variety pack is most useful when people sharing the box have different flavor preferences or when you want options for a gathering. The Tastykake assortment in this roundup includes cherry, blueberry, and lemon alongside apple, so the pack is not an apple-only restock. If each person specifically wants apple, a dedicated apple multipack gives you a more direct match. Consider how many apple portions you need before choosing the assortment. Variety can reduce flavor repetition, but it also means fewer of the flavor that prompted the purchase.
What should I check before ordering a full-size frozen apple pie?
Check the pie’s listed weight, storage requirements, and preparation directions, then make sure the size suits the number of people you plan to serve. A larger pie can be convenient for sharing, but it takes freezer space and may require more time to prepare than snack pies. Also confirm whether you want a pie to bake or heat before serving, since the schedule matters for a planned meal. Do not assume two frozen pies with different listed weights serve the same number of people. Current product packaging provides the clearest details on handling and preparation.
Which type is easiest to serve to a group with different tastes?
A mixed-flavor box gives guests more choice when not everyone wants apple, while a full apple pie is simpler when the group has already agreed on dessert. Individually portioned pies can also make serving easier because no slicing is needed, though they offer less of a shared-pie presentation. Think about whether convenience or a traditional dessert matters more for the event. If you want variety and a plated centerpiece, one assortment may not satisfy both goals. Check the stated assortment contents and plan the number of portions around your guest count.
Conclusion
For a dessert you can slice and share, Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie is my best overall choice; it is also the clearest premium-style pick in this lineup because it is a full pie rather than a snack multipack. For best value in practical terms, compare the count and size of the Hostess and JJ’s Bakery multipacks against how often your household eats them; the right fit is the pack you can use without waste. Beginners who simply want familiar, portable portions can start with a Hostess snack-pie option, while shoppers seeking a different handheld style should look at Tastykake French Apple Pies. Choose Tastykake Variety Baked Pies when a group wants several flavors, and stick to an apple-only pack when apple is the priority. For a planned shared dessert, choose a frozen pie; for quick individual snacks, choose a multipack.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
