TL;DR
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Food writer Ivy Manning says she uses Savory Choice beef demi-glace concentrate instead of French onion soup mix to season slow cooker pot roast. Her method combines one packet with water, a three-pound chuck roast, carrots and potatoes, then turns the cooking liquid into gravy. The article presents this as Manning’s personal cooking tip, not as a tested comparison of products.
Cookbook author and food writer Ivy Manning says she adds French-style flavor to slow cooker pot roast by replacing a packet of onion soup mix with Savory Choice beef demi-glace concentrate. Her recipe uses one packet diluted in water with a three-pound chuck roast, carrots and potatoes, and she says the cooking liquid becomes the base for a richer gravy.
Manning describes the approach as an update to her mother’s pot roast recipe, which used French onion soup mix. She says she remembers that version fondly but now finds it too salty and artificial-tasting. The switch to demi-glace is her personal preference; the article does not provide a side-by-side tasting or nutritional comparison between the products.
For her method, Manning seasons a three-pound tied chuck roast, places it in a slow cooker and mixes one 1.33-ounce packet of Savory Choice concentrate with three-quarters of a cup of water. She pours the mixture over the meat, then adds large peeled carrots and small unpeeled yellow potatoes. The roast cooks on low for eight to nine hours, according to her account.
After cooking, Manning separates fat from the liquid and whisks the defatted juices into a simple roux to thicken the gravy. She says the demi-glace combines with the meat’s cooking juices to create a beef-forward sauce. The article describes the concentrate’s listed ingredients as wine, vegetables, beef stock, maltodextrin, butter and beef fat. It also discloses that the publisher may earn a commission if readers buy products selected for the article.
A French-inspired pot roast with a simple swap
Food writer Ivy Manning replaces onion soup mix with beef demi-glace concentrate for a richer, beef-forward gravy. It’s her personal preference, not a tested product comparison.
The seasoning swap
The concentrate replaces the onion soup mix in Manning’s family-style pot roast.
- French onion soup mix
- Manning recalls it fondly, but now finds it too salty and artificial-tasting
- Beef demi-glace concentrate mixed with water
- Carrots and small yellow potatoes cook with the roast
From slow cooker to gravy
Dilute one packet in three-quarters of a cup of water and pour it over the roast.
Add carrots and potatoes, then cook the three-pound chuck roast on low for eight to nine hours.
Separate the fat, then whisk the defatted cooking liquid into a simple roux.
What the tip does—and doesn’t—show
A shortcut for home cooks
The shelf-stable concentrate offers a different seasoning base without making demi-glace from scratch.
A personal taste claim
There is no side-by-side tasting, sodium comparison, price analysis, or proof the swap suits every cook.
A Shortcut to Beefier Pot Roast Gravy
The tip offers home cooks a low-effort alternative to making demi-glace from scratch, a process Manning characterizes as lengthy and labor-intensive. A shelf-stable concentrate can be mixed with water and added to a slow cooker, while the roast cooks over several hours. The approach may appeal to cooks who want a different seasoning base than packaged soup mix without preparing a traditional sauce themselves.
The claimed benefit is culinary, not a verified health or cost advantage. Manning says she prefers the result’s flavor, but no independent tasting, price comparison or sodium figures are included. Readers who are monitoring salt, allergens or dietary restrictions should check the product’s current label: the article lists ingredients including butter and beef fat, but does not give a complete allergen or nutrition statement.
Products Worth Considering
Instant Pot Pro 6-Quart 10-in-1 Electric Pressure Cooker
Instant Pot RIO Wide 7.5-Quart 7-in-1 Electric Pressure Cooker
Instant Pot Duo Plus 6-Quart 9-in-1 Electric Pressure Cooker
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Soup Mix to Demi-Glace
Demi-glace is a concentrated brown sauce traditionally made by combining espagnole sauce with beef stock and wine, then simmering the mixture until reduced. Manning describes it as a rich sauce often served with meat. She says she made it during culinary school but found the process too tedious to repeat at home.
Her shortcut applies the concentrate to a familiar slow cooker pot roast rather than using it only as a finishing sauce. The underlying meal remains conventional: chuck roast cooks with root vegetables, and its juices are used for gravy. The change is the seasoning liquid, which Manning says gives the dish a French-inspired flavor.
“I still remember it fondly, [but] it’s far too salty and artificial-tasting to my palate these days.”
— Ivy Manning, food writer and cookbook author
What the Taste Claim Establishes
The article reports Manning’s own experience; it does not establish that the concentrate will taste better to other cooks or that it is less salty than onion soup mix. No sodium comparison, price analysis, blind tasting or broader product review data is provided. The product’s ingredient list and availability may also change, so readers should consult the packaging they buy.
The article says Savory Choice recommends using packets within two years of manufacture and storing them in an airtight container in a cool, dry place. It also suggests that a packet may remain safe beyond its suggested date based on smell and taste. That advice is not backed by further food-safety details in the article; date guidance and package instructions should be checked, and tasting should not be treated as a reliable test of whether food is safe.
Readers Can Test the Swap
No product announcement or follow-up test is described. The next step for interested cooks is to try Manning’s method, following the concentrate’s package directions and checking the current ingredient and allergen information. Because slow-cooker timing can vary by appliance and roast, cooks should follow safe handling guidance and confirm the meat is fully cooked before serving.
The article invites readers to share their own pot roast seasoning tips, but it does not report a response or a planned comparison of demi-glace and onion soup mix. Whether the swap changes the dish’s flavor, salt level or cost for a particular household remains a matter for cooks to assess using the products and portions they choose.
Source: rss
Key Questions
What does Ivy Manning use instead of onion soup mix?
She uses one 1.33-ounce packet of Savory Choice beef demi-glace concentrate, mixed with three-quarters of a cup of water.
How long does Manning cook the pot roast?
Her method cooks a three-pound chuck roast on low for eight to nine hours, with carrots and small potatoes in the slow cooker.
How does she make gravy from the cooking liquid?
Manning separates the fat from the liquid, then whisks the defatted juices into a simple roux to thicken them.
Is demi-glace concentrate proven to be less salty than soup mix?
No comparison is provided. Manning says she finds her mother’s onion-soup-mix version too salty, but the article gives no sodium figures or product-to-product test.
How should the concentrate be stored?
The article says Savory Choice recommends storing packets in an airtight container in a cool, dry place and using them within two years of manufacture. Check the package for current instructions and date guidance.
Source: thekitchn.com
